Our Menu
Starters
Garlic Bread (V)
$6.00
$8.00/with Cheese
Marinara | Add Wisconsin Mozzarella Cheese +$2.00
*Eggplant Fries (V)
$12.00
Buttermilk-marinated, creamy parmesan dressing, marinara
Parmesan Truffle Fries (V)
$12.00
Truffle aïoli, parmesan, sea salt
Meatball Marinara
$15.00/+
4 House-made meatballs made of ground beef Vinny’s Italian sausage and marinara.
Crispy Brussels Sprouts (GF)
$12.00
Bacon, American Grana Padano, Calabrian chili honey, herbs
Wonton Wrapped Mozzarella Sticks (V)
$9.00/+
3 Wonton Wrapped with Marinara
Crispy Calamari
$16.00
Buttermilk and herb marinated, pepperoncini, marinara
Burrata Della Casa
$18.00
Fresh Mozzarella Cheese Filled with shreds of mozzarella infused in cream layered with Prosciutto di Parma served with crostini
Olive Della Casa
$10.00
Castelvetrano, cerignola olives with fresh herbs, olive oil
Antipasto
$18.00
Pistacchio Mortadella, Salami Finocchiona, Hot Soppressata, Provolone Cheese, Fontina Cheese, Marinated Olives
Bruschetta Tradizionale
$12.00
Diced roma tomato, garlic, basil, balsamic, crostini drizzled with balsamic glaze
Salads
Add Grilled Chicken +$6.00 | Crispy Chicken +8.00
*Shaved Brussels Sprouts (V, GF)
$9.00
$13.00
Arugula, Door County dried cherries, ricotta salata, toasted hazelnuts, charred lemon vinaigrette
Chopped (GF)
$9.00
$13.00
Seasonal greens, salami, garbanzo beans, Kalamata and Castelvetrano olives, celery smoked provolone, cucumber, red onion, tomato, red wine vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
$8.00
$12.00
Romaine, parmesan, garlic bread crouton, original Pizza Man Caesar dressing.
Garden (V)
$7.00
$10.00
Seasonal greens, crouton, cucumber, pickled carrots, red onion, tomato, herb ranch dressing
Pasta
Sub Gluten Free Spaghetti +$2.00 | Add a Side Garden Salad or A Side Caesar Salad +$4.00
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$19.00
Red sauce, American Grana Padano, herbs
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
$21.00
Garlic cream sauce, American Grana Padano
Chicken Parmesan
$24.00
Red sauce, spaghetti, fresh mozzarella, parmesan
Spicy Rigatoni a La Vodka
$19.00
Vodka sauce, Vinny’s Italian sausage, Calabrian peppers, parmesan.
Shrimp Scampi
$25.00
Linguine Pasta, 7 jumbo shrimp tail on, extra virgin olive oil,fresh garlic, fresh herbs in a white wine butter sauce
Creamy Marsala Pasta
$23.00
Orecchiette pasta, sautéed spicy Italian sausage link, with mushroom and onions in a creamy marsala sauce
Chicken Marsala
$24.00
Two lightly breaded chicken breasts topped with mushroom and onion creamy marsala sauce served with sautéed brussell sprouts
Specialty Pizza
Small 12” | Large 16” | All pizzas are created with Wisconsin mozzarella. Our fermented thin cracker crust is prepared in-house. Our specialty pizzas have been designed and crafted by our Pizza Man chefs. They are meant to be enjoyed as-is. Please limit modifications to two per specialty pizza | Sauce It Up for +$ 1: Marinara, Pesto Ranch, Creamy Parmesan, Herbed Buttermilk Ranch, Calabrian Hot Honey, Truffle Aioli, Honey BBQ
Pizza Man Special
$21.00/12"
$27.00/16"
Classic sauce, pepperoni, Vinny’s Italian sausage, green pepper, yellow onion, mushroom, black olive
*Milwaukee
$18.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Classic sauce, Vinny’s Italian sausage, mushroom, yellow onion
Carnivoro
$20.00/12"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, pepperoni, Vinny’s Italian sausage, salami, bacon
*Bianca (V)
$18.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Garlic cream sauce, cream cheese, mushroom, truffle oil, American Grana Padano, arugula
Veggie Supreme (V)
$18.00/12"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, black olive, tomato, green pepper, mushroom, yellow onion
Pizza Man Margherita (V)
$19.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Italia red sauce, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, EVOO
BBQ Chicken
$19.00/12"
$25.00/16"
BBQ sauce, cheddar, cilantro, chicken, cream cheese, red onion, pickled banana pepper
Pesto Pig
$20.00/12"
$25.00/16"
Basil pesto, porchetta, red wine-pickled onion, goat cheese, fried basil, oven-roasted tomato
*Atomica
$20.00/12"
$25.00/16"
Italia red sauce, spicy soppressata, prosciutto, Calabrian pepper, oregano, red onion, smoked provolone
Hawaiian
$19.00/12"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, Canadian bacon, caramelized pineapple, cream cheese
King - Roni
$19.00/12"
$25.00/16"
Classic sauce, pepperoni cups, diced pepperoni, pepperoni, American Grana Padano, chili flake, oregano
Topher
$18.00/12"
$23.00/16"
Classic sauce, Vinny’s Italian sausage, Calabrian chili honey, cream cheese, pickled jalapeño
Artichoke A La Mode (V)
$19.00/12"
$24.00/16"
Classic sauce, artichoke, tomato, chopped garlic, basil, cream cheese
Build Your Own
Small 12” | Large 16”
The Orginal Thin Crust
$13.00/12"
$17.00/16"
Pan Crust
$16.00/12"
Deep Dish
$18.00/12"
Gluten Free Crust
$17.00/10“
Choose Your Sauce:
Classic Sauce (V+) | Red Sauce (V+) | Garlic Cream Sauce (V) | Basil Pesto (V) | BBQ sauce (V+)
CHOOSE YOUR TOPPINGS:
Prices are per topping. All Build-Your-Own pizzas are created with Wisconsin mozzarella
Premium Topping:
$3.00
$5.50
Meatball, Prosciutto, Soppressata, Pancetta
Proteins:
$2.00
$5.00
Anchovies, Bacon, Chicken, Canadian Bacon, Genoa Salami, Grilled Chicken, Pepperoni, Pepperoni Cups, Pepperoni Diced, Vinny’s Italian Sausage
Cheeses:
$2.00
$4.00
Wisconsin mozzarella, Cheddar, Cream cheese, Fresh mozzarella, Goat cheese, Smoked provolone, Parmesan
Veggies:
$1.50
$2.50
Artichoke, Arugula, Black olive, Calabrian pepper, Chopped garlic, Fresh basil, Fresh oregano, Green pepper, Grilled pineapple, Kalamata olives, Green Olives, Mushroom, Pickled banana pepper, Pickled jalapeńo, Red wine pickled onion, Red onion, Spinach, Yellow onion
Desserts
Seasonal Cheesecake (V)
$8.00
Ask your server for seasonal toppings.
Tiramisu (V)
$8.00
Espresso-soaked ladyfingers, mascarpone cheese, shaved chocolate
Italian Gelato (V, GF)
$6.00
Vanilla, chocolate, or salted caramel
Cannoli
$7.00
Cannoli filling with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips